Print This Post

US Parkinson’s rates highest in whites, Hispanics, and Midwest, Northeast

The largest epidemiological study of Parkinson’s disease in the United States has found that the disease is more common in the Midwest and the Northeast and is twice as likely to strike whites and Hispanics as blacks and Asians.

The study, based on data from 36 million Medicare recipients, is both the first to produce any significant information on patterns of Parkinson’s disease in minorities and to show geographic clusters for the condition.
“Finding clusters in the Midwest and the Northeast is particularly exciting,” says lead author Allison Wright Willis, M.D., assistant professor of neurology at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis. “These are the two regions of the country most involved in metal processing and agriculture, and chemicals used in these fields are the strongest potential environmental risk factors for Parkinson’s disease that we’ve identified so far.”
The results appear online in the journal Neuroepidemiology.
Parkinson’s disease is a common neurodegenerative condition that causes tremor, stiffness, slowness, mood and behavioral disorders, sleep problems and other symptoms. The disease is characterized by loss of dopamine, a compound involved in communication between brain cells.
According to Willis, genetic factors explain only a small percent of cases. Environmental factors are likely more common contributors and may include prolonged exposures to herbicides and insecticides used in farming or to metals such as copper, manganese and lead.
For the new study, Willis analyzed data on more than 450,000 cases of Parkinson’s disease per year over six years, 1995 and 2000-2005. Collectively, that data included information from more than 98 percent of all Americans 65 and older.
Willis found Asians and blacks developed Parkinson’s disease at half the rate of whites and Hispanics.
“We are going to try to learn more about why this is the case,” says Willis. “It could be that those with Asian or African ancestry have genes that help protect them from exposure to environmental factors that cause Parkinson’s disease, or they may have fewer exposures to those factors.”
Epidemiologists have long debated whether Parkinson’s disease is more prevalent in rural or urban areas, with some studies showing higher rates in cities and some in the countryside. Willis found the condition is more common in urban areas but concluded the comparison between the two rates offered little potential for insight into the disease.
“It’s always been an open question as to how to best define the terms ‘urban’ and ‘rural,’” she says. “Urban and rural is defined in many different and relatively arbitrary ways, and we came away convinced by our results that these distinctions have little to do with what is causing the disease.”
Willis and her colleagues plan further studies of how exposure to single or combined environmental factors influences disease risk.
“This was the largest descriptive epidemiological study yet to be conducted of Parkinson’s disease in the United States, and it has both given us some interesting new leads for the future research and reinforced some ideas we already had,” she says.
More information: Wright Willis A, Evanoff BA, Lian M, Criswell SR, Racette BA. Geographic and ethnic variation in Parkinson disease: a population-based study of US Medicare beneficiaries. Neuroepidemiology, 2010;34:143-151
Provided by Washington University School of Medicine (news : web)

Print This Post

Wii benefits Parkinson’s patients

Print This Post

Treadmill Training Improves Walking in Parkinson’s

By Michael Smith, North American Correspondent, MedPage Today
Published: January 20, 2010
Reviewed by Zalman S. Agus, MD; Emeritus Professor
University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine and
Dorothy Caputo, MA, RN, BC-ADM, CDE, Nurse Planner
Earn CME/CE credit
for reading medical news

Treadmill training can improve the impaired walking associated with Parkinson’s disease, researchers said.

The technique leads to improvements in gait speed, stride length, and walking distance, but not gait cadence, according to Jan Mehrholz, PhD, of the Klinik Bavaria in Kreischa, Germany, and colleagues.

However, it remains unclear how long such improvements last, the researchers noted in a Cochrane Systematic Review.

Treadmill training has emerged recently as a “promising investigational therapy” aimed at patients with weakness on one side of the body and impaired gait, Mehrholz and colleagues wrote in their review.

To evaluate what’s known about the subject, the researchers searched the literature and found eight randomized, controlled studies with a total of 203 participants.
Action Points
Explain to interested patients that treadmill training is a promising therapy for gait impairments in people with Parkinson’s disease.

Note that this review suggests the evidence so far is in favor of the idea, but calls for more research.
On average, patients were 61, with an average duration of disease in the studies ranging from one to eight years.
When the studies were analyzed, the researchers found:

Seven studies — with153 participants all told — found that treadmill training improved gait speed. The pooled standardized mean difference was 0.50, which was significant at P=0.003.
Five studies, with a total of 95 participants, looked at stride length and found that treadmill training was beneficial. The pooled standardized mean difference was 0.50, which was significant at P=0.05.
Two studies, with 41 participants, found that treadmill training improved walking distance. The mean difference was 358 meters, which was significant at P<0.0001.
Finally, four studies (with 78 participants) found no significant mean difference in cadence.
The treadmill training was acceptable to patients, the researchers said, in that it did not increase the risk of patients dropping out of studies. Adverse events were not reported.

The researchers noted that the study protocols varied markedly.

The treadmill training lasted from one 30-minute session to eight weeks, although most studies used a four-, six- or eight-week period. Frequency varied from a single session to four times a week, the researchers said.

The type of treadmill training also varied, with some investigators using body-weight supported treadmill training and others a speed-dependent approach.

Primary outcomes also differed, Mehrholz and colleagues said.

Because of those variations, they said, there is “still a need for well-designed large-scale studies” to look at the risk and benefits of treadmill training for Parkinson’s patients.

Specifically, they said, those studies should address open questions about how long the effect lasts and what should be the frequency and duration of training.

Print This Post

Dawn of a new Decade

When we get to New Year’s Eve we become nostalgic, and usually reflect on the year just passed. This past New Year’s Eve added the dimension of a decade of time and the reflection grew deeper as you pondered the ten year time span. Just think about the events. Probably the most indelible is the terrorist attacks of 2001. Do you recall “hanging chads?”
We were reminded that space travel is anything but ordinary when the Columbia disintegrated before our eyes. We were introduced to Wikipedia, youtube, Twitter, Facebook, blogs, Blackberries, Ipod, and HDTV. Of course we had endings as well. Pluto lost its status as a planet. Harry Potter had his final book, the Concorde’s final flight, ENRON, and Polaroid. We lost Ronald Reagan, Pope John Paul II, Bob Hope, Michael Jackson, Roone Arlidge, Ted Williams, Peter Jennings, and Rosa Parks.

It was a decade when Parkinson’s Disease (PD) came to the forefront when the stereotypical image that it is a disease of the elderly, was shattered with the announcement by 34 year old Michael J Fox that he has Parkinson’s.

My world changed as well. With my diagnosis of Early Onset Parkinson’s Disease in 2004, I began a dual life. By day, I remain the mild mannered self-storage executive that I have been since 1991. However, by night I turn into a crusader, an advocate for those, like me, with Parkinson’s Disease.

This letter is about youth, hope, vision and Parkinson’s Disease. When I write the decade review for the 2020 newsletter, let us hope the “endings” include the disease known as Parkinson’s.

Mike’s Story

Mike Justak- ” A cup of coffee?”

When diagnosed in 2004 my first impression was relief. After all, I was expecting worse news- something fatal. I didn’t know what Parkinson’s was or its impact. But still feeling “ashamed” I went into denial. It was a year before I could start telling people my “secret”. On Easter Sunday 2006, I was offered “insight”, an answer to the question of,”Why me?” That insight led to the creation of a nonprofit to benefit Parkinson’s Disease. What should I call It? Well, It strives to create new partners or partnerships to help those with PD. “Parnterships for Parkinson’s”, or PFP, Inc. was born.

In 2008, while attending a conference on Early Onset PD, I met David Zid. David is a crusader as well. His book “Delay the Disease” offers an step by step guide to exercises that have shown to slow the progression of the disease. PFP was a proud sponsor of David’s trip and symposium to the Twin Cities. Is David effective? During his interactive talk, a participant using techniques demonstrated by David, rose unassited from a chair for the first time in months.

In 2009, the redesign of the website,offering video information on Parkinson’s, was launched.The blog also continues to experience good traffic counts. Yet I fall short of my dream. My mission is to help those-first hand.

Parkinson’s is a movement disorder. Movement. Movement therapies. An area of opportunity. The Wii game system has actually shown to be beneficial to Parkinson’s patients. It’s benefits are two-fold. As a “social” gaming system it also helps alliviate the depression that is commonplace to Parkinson’s.

Depression and isolation. Patients are urged to be part of various support groups. Participation can be sidelined by inability to drive, weather, or just the general health of the participant. Enabling various support groups with the capeability to conduct video conferencing of support group meetings can open vistas deemed closed.

And of course-research into a cure. This three sided approach is my vision for use of funds raised by PFP in 2010.

So, how ‘ bout that coffee. My favorite is the seasonal offering of local provider Caribou Coffee, Ho Ho Mocha. Ok, I know the name is sillly, but it adds some fun to the ‘ol cup of Joe. Anyway, the medium is $3.10. You’re joining me—right? So that brings it to $6.20 plus tax. You’re the courteous type so you offer to buy—Thanks! That was mighty nice of you. Add a tip and you’re at seven bucks.

Do this for me. Click the link:

www.MikesWalkforPD.com

Click “donate” and put the $7 to a better use. If you can, buy a few rounds. Or better yet, buy for the “house” and go for a sponsor role.

So I don’t get my HO HO Mocha. I’ll be OK-I’ll just brew a cup instead, but your simple gesture, a cup of coffee can IMPACT the lives of those with Parkinson’s Disease.

You’ll find your next cup of coffee never tasted sooooo good,

A Story about Hope and Support
Importance of Support

The lives of Jenny Davis, 42, and Tina Lagonegro, 37, resemble the lives of so many other busy, involved moms. They lead their “team” each day, raising them to be responsible, strong individuals while juggling the daily responsibilities faced by any family. Between the two families, there are 10 children ranging in age from three years to age 19. So go the normal lives of these two families.

Davis and Lagonegro, along with their husbands, face all the same joys and challenges as so many other families. Their “normal” lives have not disappeared, but Parkinson’s disease forces them to adjust constantly. They have both come to accept a “new normal”.

Living with YOPD requires careful management of symptoms, treatments and the effects this has on families, lives and careers. Finding the right support mechanism to assist with this is critical.

“I didn’t need anyone telling me how awful it was that I was dealing with this disease. What I needed was to hear from others who were getting through day-to-day life,” says Davis.

Sharing stories of health insurance struggles, drug side-effects, solutions, dealing with troublesome symptoms and developing positive friendships are all key to maintaining a quality of life beyond the disease.

“For me a support group isn’t just a group that gathers once a month to talk about having the disease, it’s a group of people who support each other in living life.”
For Davis and Lagonegro, balancing daily life and staying busy keep them moving forward-even if sometimes that movement is not as smooth as it was in the past. Focusing on their families and their faith while acknowledging the limitations that the disease imposes, helps both of them take each day as it comes.

Both women agree: “Life is very different now than it once was, but it is a good life and we appreciate every moment we have.”

Michigan Dynamic Duo

When Bay City’s Joan Szczepanski started a support group four years ago for younger people with Parkinson’s disease, she was seeking help for herself.
Diagnosed with the movement disorder at age 51, she didn’t fit in with other Parkinson’s groups whose members are usually older, she said. “You can only read so much, but you don’t really know until you see it first-hand. We formed on prayer and hope and it worked out.”

Leaders at the Michigan Parkinson’s Foundation asked Szczepanski, now 56, to start the group to meet needs such as hers. As a facilitator, she brings in speakers and coordinates sessions as a volunteer with educational assistance from the foundation. “It is more than I thought it would be and I can’t believe the response we get from doctors who speak to the group and send patients to us,” she said. “We are a family…these are people who really understand.” Carolyn Weaver of Freeland, another longtime group member, now helps Szczepanski lead meetings and provides great encouragement.

Diagnosed 10 years ago, Weaver deals with constant muscle “freezing” that makes her feel her feet are glued to the ground. But she continues to work as a marketing representative for Berner Medical Systems, Lakeshore Diagnostic Ultrasound and RediMed, traveling to meet clients and conduct training sessions. “I can drive, but with Parkinson’s, it depends on the day. You are either on or really off,” she said. “So I get rides and help from co-workers. I really want to continue working and stay active. I want to let people know there is life after Parkinson’s.” Weaver, now 58, takes medication every three hours to control symptoms — as does Szczepanski, who deals with muscle tremors and loss of sleep. The disease affects every person differently, making research a challenge. But Weaver is helping to improve the search for a cure. She was one of 25 people chosen last year by the national Parkinson’s Disease Foundation to take part in an institute dedicated to educating people about the need for more clinical research. “Less than 1 percent of Parkinson’s patients participate (in clinical research). We need more data to move forward (toward a cure),” Weaver said. She makes presentations about clinical research trials to doctors and patient groups and will help lead a second institute this fall. She recently took part in a study at the University of Michigan on gait disorders such as the freezing that stops her walking.
They hope to continue to grow the support group and have formed a second group for care partners, such as spouses or other family members. Both women get great support from their husbands, they said. They even have plans to bring a dance instructor to group meetings because dancing can help with controlling movement, Szczepanski said.

“It’s a wonderful group of people and it’s encouraging,” said Weaver. “We have a policy to stay positive.”

Mike’s Walk for Parkinson’s Disease

This April 24, in New York City’s Central Park, Mike Justak will join tens of thousands who will “walk” to benefit Parkinson’s Disease. The New York Walk is the largest gathering of its kind in the US Parkinson’s community.

Parkinson’s Disease is a neurological movement disorder for which there is no cure. Over one million Americans currently have Parkinson’s. Nearly one in five of those diagnsed are under the age of fifty.

Hey,
Don’t forget the coffee.
Here’s how to make it a “Grande”.
Forward this email to someone you know. Ask them to buy us both a cup of coffee.
See if your employer has gift matches. You may be able to make that cup a double!
Lastly think about how you might Introduce me to someone who might have an interest in sponsoring my team.

A few clicks. Take that step. Walk with me.

Sincerely yours,
Mike, Karen, and Family
Mike’s Walk for PD supports the misson of PFP, Inc.
PFP, Inc. is an IRS approved 501(c)3 Minnesota Nonprofit Public Charity whose mission is to create awareness, educate the public, and raise funds to improve the lives of those living with Parkinson’s Disease.

Your gift to PFP, Inc. may qualify for tax preferences. Check with your tax advisor.

FEIN: 20-8245231

Print This Post

Mike’s Walk

Print This Post

Mike’s Walk for Parkinson’s Disease

On April 24, 2010, Mike Justak will join the thousands gathering in New York City’s Central Park and walk in support of those with Parkinson’s disease. The New York walk is the largest of its kind. Details on Mike’s effort can be found at:

MikesWalkforPD.com

Print This Post

Progression Of Parkinson’s Disease May Be Prevented By Widely Used Cholesterol-Lowering Drug

Simvastatin, a commonly used, cholesterol-lowering drug, may prevent Parkinson’s disease from progressing further. Neurological researchers at Rush University Medical Center conducted a study examining the use of the FDA-approved medication in mice with Parkinson’s disease and found that the drug successfully reverses the biochemical, cellular and anatomical changes caused by the disease.

“Statins are one of the most widely used cholesterol-lowering drugs throughout the world,” said study author Kalipada Pahan, PhD, professor of neurological sciences at Rush University Medical Center. “This may be a safer approach to halt the disease progression in Parkinson’s patients.”

Pahan and colleagues from Rush, along with researchers at the University of Nebraska Medical Center in Omaha published these findings in the October 28 issue of the Journal of Neurosciences.

The authors have shown that the activity of one protein called p21Ras is increased very early in the midbrain of mice with Parkinson’s pathology. Simvastatin enters into the brain and blocks the activity of the p21Ras protein and other associated toxic molecules, and goes on to protect the neurons, normalize neurotransmitter levels, and improves the motor functions in the mice with Parkinson’s.

“Understanding how the disease works is important to developing effective drugs that protect the brain and stop the progression of Parkinson’s,” said Pahan. “If we are able to replicate these results in Parkinson’s patients in the clinical setting, it would be a remarkable advance in the treatment of this devastating neurodegenerative disease.”

The study was supported by grants from National Institutes of Health and Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Research.

Parkinson’s is a slowly progressive disease that affects a small area of cells within the mid-brain known as the substantia nigra. Gradual degeneration of these cells causes a reduction in dopamine, which is a vital chemical neurotransmitter. The decrease in dopamine results in one or more of the classic signs of Parkinson’s disease that includes, resting tremor on one side of the body, generalized slowness of movement, stiffness of limbs, and gait or balance problems. The cause of Parkinson’s disease is unknown. Both environmental and genetic causes of the disease have been postulated.

Parkinson’s disease affects about 1.2 million patients in the United States and Canada. Although 15 percent of patients are diagnosed before age 50, it is generally considered a disease that targets older adults, affecting one of every 100 persons over the age of 60. This disease appears to be slightly more common in men than women.

Source: Deborah Song
Rush University Medical Center

Print This Post

Hope For Possible Parkinson’s Disease Cure From ISU Researchers’ Findings

Researchers at Iowa State University have found an essential key to possibly cure Parkinson’s disease and are looking for others.

Anumantha Kanthasamy, a distinguished professor of biomedical sciences and W. Eugene and Linda R. Lloyd Endowed Chair in Neurotoxicology at the ISU College of Veterinary Medicine, has been working to understand the complex mechanisms of the disease for more than a decade and thinks he has found hope for the cure.

Parkinson’s disease sufferers lack a sufficient amount of a brain chemical called dopamine.

Kanthasamy’s research shows that there is specific protein that is naturally present in human brains that — for no known reason — kills the brain cells that make dopamine.

The cells that are being killed are the ones that produce the needed dopamine.

“We have millions of cells in our brains,” said Kanthasamy, “In Parkinson’s, about 10,000 of these brain cells die; no one knows why.”

Kanthasamy discovered that a novel protein — known as protein kinase-C (specifically PKCδ) - is killing the dopamine-producing cells.

Kanthasamy and his research staff discovered a compound that neutralizes the cell-killing kinase-C and allows the dopamine-producing cells to survive and function.

“With a lot of hard work, and little bit of luck, we found something important,” he said. “And when you find something like this you say, ‘This is great because it can be a target for developing new drugs.’”

Now, Kanthasamy’s group is looking for additional compounds that also can serve to neutralize protein kinase-C. By identifying more compounds that perform the function of neutralizing kinase-C, researchers are more likely to locate one that works well and has few side effects.

This discovery is expected to provide new treatment options to stop the progression of the disease or even cure it.

The study is being funded by a Grow Iowa Values Fund grant. The goal of the grant program is to support development of technologies with commercial potential and to support the growth of companies using those technologies. Kanthasamy is working on this research with PK Biosciences Corp., an Iowa-based startup company. Funding was also provided by the National Institutes of Health.

“Once we find the compound, we need to make sure it’s safe. If everything goes well, it could take about 10 years, and then we might be able to see something that will truly make a difference in the lives of people with this disorder,” said Kanthasamy.

Parkinson’s disease strikes around 50,000 people each year, and there are approximately 1 million people with the disease. Parkinson’s sufferers include actor Michael J. Fox and former boxing champion Muhammad Ali.

As people grow older, the cells that produce dopamine naturally die, causing dopamine levels to fall gradually over time. When the levels continue to drop below 60 to 70 percent, the person will start to have Parkinson’s disease symptoms, according to Kanthasamy.

“Everybody has a little Parkinson’s in theory,” he said. “But you can’t see it until the level of dopamine gets too low.”

Eliminating the symptoms of Parkinson’s disease doesn’t require people to be restored to 100 percent of previous dopamine levels, but only to a fraction of that.

“If you can bring dopamine up to the 40-50 percent level, you’ll see a functioning, normal person,” he said.

Currently, there is no cure for Parkinson’s and available therapies only treat the symptoms.

Major contributing factors for getting Parkinson’s disease include prolonged exposure to metals or pesticides and other environmental chemicals, according to Kanthasamy.

Symptoms of Parkinson’s disease include trembling in hands, arms, legs, jaw, and face; rigidity or stiffness of the limbs and trunk; slowness of movement; and impaired balance and coordination. As these symptoms become more pronounced, patients may have difficulty walking, talking, or completing other simple tasks. Because the disease typically affects people over the age of 50, the National Institutes of Health anticipates the incidence of Parkinson’s will increase as the nation’s population ages.

Source: Anumantha Kanthasamy
Iowa State University

Print This Post

Rasagiline Said to Delay Parkinson Progression

By John Gever, Senior Editor, MedPage Today

Final results from a closely watched trial of rasagiline (Azilect) in Parkinson’s disease suggested the drug slowed the illness’s progression, study leaders said, but outside experts voice doubts.

Patients receiving 1 mg/day of rasagiline for 72 weeks showed a mean 2.82-point worsening of symptoms compared with a 4.52-point change among patients in a “delayed start” group who received placebo for 36 weeks followed by rasagiline for 36 weeks (P=0.02), according to a report in the Sept. 24 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.

The difference is an indication that rasagiline did not merely alleviate Parkinson symptoms, but actually slowed the loss of neuronal function that causes the disease, wrote C. Warren Olanow, MD, of Mt. Sinai School of Medicine in New York City, and colleagues.

In a press release issued by Mt. Sinai, Olanow said the findings, if confirmed, would be “one of the biggest advances made in Parkinson’s in six years.”Action Points
Explain to interested patients that there is currently no treatment known to delay progression of the underlying pathology of Parkinson’s disease, although several therapies are available to relieve symptoms.

Explain that rasagiline is FDA-approved for symptomatic treatment of Parkinson’s disease. However, the findings of this study that it may modify the underlying pathology need confirmation in additional studies.

Explain, too, that the potential disease-modifying effect was measured indirectly and was not apparent with a higher drug dose.
The study, called ADAGIO, had strength of numbers — 1,176 patients with untreated, early-stage Parkinson’s disease. The delayed-start trial design is an attempt to detect a disease-modifying effect for a condition that doesn’t lend itself to direct measures — which in this case would likely require brain biopsies.

Because this approach is relatively new, the NEJM included a primer on the delayed-start design by Ralph B. D’Agostino Sr., PhD, a statistician at Boston University.

He wrote that Olanow and colleagues achieved “some success” with ADAGIO.

But the investigators themselves cautioned that the results were somewhat ambiguous, as no disease-modifying effect was seen with a higher rasagiline dose. Patients taking 2 mg/day in the early- and delayed-start groups had nearly identical changes on the Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) scores — 3.47 points with the early start versus 3.11 points with the delayed start (P=0.60).

“Given the negative findings for the 2-mg dose, we cannot definitively conclude that rasagiline at a dose of 1 mg per day has disease-modifying effects,” Olanow and colleagues conceded.

Some of the data had been presented earlier at scientific meetings, priming the Parkinson’s disease research community for responses — much of which was critical.

Peter LeWitt, MD, a neurologist at Henry Ford Hospital in Detroit, questioned whether the disase-modifying effect seen in the trial was clinically significant, even if it was real.

On the basis of early presentations of the trial data, LeWitt wrote in Neurology in April that the reported effect barely made a dent in the expected disease progression.

“The small clinical improvements . . . need to be contrasted with the typical rate of progression in early Parkinson’s disease, whose annual mean change ranges from 6.31 to 10.46 UPDRS units,” LeWitt wrote.

Other experts contacted by MedPage Today and ABC News generally agreed.

“I would be reluctant to accept the conclusion that this provides compelling evidence of slowed Parkinson’s disease progression,” said J. Eric Ahlskog, MD, PhD, of the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn.

Even one investigator in the trial cast doubt on the study’s importance.

William Weiner, MD, chairman of neurology at the University of Maryland, said he disagreed with the NEJM report’s emphasis on the possible disease-modifying effect.

“I was never given the opportunity to review the article and I would not have agreed to stressing the neuroprotection angle so strongly,” he wrote in an e-mail.

He said the primary outcome ended up as less than two points’ difference on the 176-point UPDRS scale. “[It is] maybe statistically significant, but it is surely not clinically meaningful,” Weiner said.

Joanne Wojcieszek, MD, of Indiana University in Indianapolis, noted that rasagiline — a monoamine oxidase B inhibitor — involves dietary precautions and a long list of other medications to avoid. “It takes a lot of time to explain this med to patients,” she said.

She also said the drug is expensive. The online pharmacy Drugs.com lists a price of $311 for a month’s supply of the 1-mg dose.

In the ADAGIO trial, patients with at least two of the three major symptoms of Parkinson’s disease — resting tremor, bradykinesia, and rigidity — not previously receiving chronic treatments were eligible to participate.

Participants were rated on the UPDRS at baseline and 10 subsequent visits during the 72-week trial.

Three primary endpoints were evaluated: average weekly change in UPDRS score over weeks 12 to 36, showing slower change in the early-start group versus placebo; less change in the early-start group in total UPDRS change from baseline to week 72, which would reflect a disease-modifying effect; and noninferiority of the early-started treatment to delayed start in the rate of change in UPDRS scores over weeks 48 to 72, when all patients were taking rasagiline.

The researchers said the 1-mg dose met all three endpoints, but the 2-mg dose met only the first and third.

Olanow and colleagues offered a possible explanation for the lack of disease-modifying effect with the 2-mg dose. They suggested it may have been so effective at reducing Parkinson symptoms in both treatment groups that the slowed progression in the underlying pathology was masked.

They said the results with the 1-mg dose “cannot be readily explained by an effect on symptoms alone, since both groups received the same treatment for the last nine months of the study.”

The possibility of a disease-modifying effect was supported by laboratory studies showing that rasagiline and its primary metabolite protect neurons from various toxins.

The researchers said they had avoided at least some of the pitfalls involved with delayed-start trials identified by D’Agostino:

Dropout rates remained low during the placebo phase, reducing the bias that dropouts introduce.
Randomization should have minimized problems associated with misdiagnosis of early-stage patients.
Although average weekly change in UPDRS score is not a standard measure of disease progression, the findings were confirmed with categorical analyses.
The finding of an apparent disease-modifying effect with the 1-mg dose provided assurance that the placebo phase was not too short.
Despite the skepticism voiced by others, one prominent neurologist told MedPage Today and ABC News that the ADAGIO results were persuasive and immediately practice-changing.

“I do believe that this constitutes a major advance in Parkinson’s,” wrote Daniel Kremens, MD, of Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia, in an e-mail. “From this study alone and the use of this drug, the paradigm of Parkinson’s treatment really should shift.”

He said it was no longer appropriate to initiate drug treatment only after symptoms become disabling.

“We should no longer be waiting. We should consider starting [patients] on treatment as soon as diagnosis is made with hope that we can modify the disease course. And that’s a major change in how Parkinson’s is treated currently,” Kremens wrote.

Teva supported the ADAGIO study.

Olanow and colleagues reported relationships with Teva, Lundbeck, Boehringer Ingelheim, Novartis/Orion, Solvay, Ceregene, Merck Serono, Ceregene, Eisai, Eutherapie, GlaxoSmithKline, Osmotica, Schering-Plough, Pierre Fabre, Allergan Neuroscience, Alphamedica, ApotheCom, Axis Healthcare, Bayer Schering, CNS Schering-Plough, Centopharm, Embryon, Genzyme, Impax, Ipsen, Kyowa, Merck, Ortho-McNeil, Pfizer, Prestwick, Quintiles, Santhera, Schwarz Pharma, Valeant Pharm, Vernalis, Acadia, SkyePharma, UCB Pharma, INC Research, Mentor, Asubio, i3 Research, Chelsea Therapeutics, Advanced Neuromodulation Systems, Medtronic Neurological, Neurogen, and Orion.

D’Agostino reported being a special employee of the FDA, but had no relationships with industry.

Lewitt reported relationships with Allergan, Boehringer-Ingelheim, GlaxoSmithKline, Novartis, Schwarz Pharma (now UCB), Solstice, Vernalis, Asubio, Brittania, Eisai, Impax, Kyowa, Neurim, Neuroderm, Neurologix, Orion, Prestwick, Spherics, XenoPort, Merck & Co., Santhera, Schering-Plough, Supernus, Valeant, and Chelsea Therapeutics.

Wojcieszek reported a relationship with Teva.

Ahlskog reported no potential conflicts.

Weiner reported relationships with Teva, Boehringer Ingelheim, Santhera, Biogen Idec, and Novartis.

Kremens reported a relationship with Teva.

Print This Post

OLFACTORY DYSFUNCTION —AN EARLY DIAGNOSTIC FOR PARKINSON’S DISEASE

SAN DIEGO—A simple smell test may soon be used to aid the diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease and to identify relatives and others at risk for the disease. Research on the use of smell tests in Parkinson’s disease was presented at the 58th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Neurology.

Since at least 1955, hyposmia has been known to occur in patients with Parkinson’s disease, according to Nicolaas Bohnen, MD, Associate Professor of Radiology and Neurology at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor. But interest in the phenomenon has grown markedly in the past few years, driven by the hope of developing neuroprotective treatment for patients in the early stage of the disorder. “The idea is to have biomarkers for early diagnosis,” said Dr. Bohnen, “and this interest is related to neuroprotective treatment.” While no definitive neuroprotective treatment has emerged, recent studies of coenzyme Q10 and rasagiline have hinted that such a therapy might be possible.

PASSING THE SMELL TEST

Dr. Bohnen’s team sought to determine whether a selective pattern of smell deficit might exist in patients with Parkinson’s disease. They used the University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test (UPSIT), a self-administered battery of 40 scratch-and-sniff odors ranging from turpentine to roses to pizza. The researchers compared smell ability in 26 Parkinson’s disease patients and 26 controls matched for age, sex, and smoking history.
The investigators found that patients with Parkinson’s disease did worse compared with controls on identifying eight odors (listed here in order of decreasing odor identification): licorice, coconut, banana, dill pickle, paint thinner, turpentine, cherry, and soap. Patients were better able to distinguish only one smell: lemon.

The existence of a selective deficit corroborates well with findings from a similar study in the United Kingdom, although there were some differences. In particular, British patients especially had trouble identifying wintergreen, while the American patients in Dr. Bohnen’s study had fewer difficulties in identifying this odor. “The cultural affinity for specific smells may differ between groups, as people are more exposed in daily life to specific smells,” he said. Difficulty recognizing banana was common to both groups.

“I’m unaware of any good explanation for why there is this specific deficit in Parkinson’s disease,” said Dr. Bohnen. While the disease is characterized by well-described pathology in the olfactory nucleus, “smell recognition is also a cognitive function. It’s relatively complex.”
Whatever the underlying physiology, the selective pattern may provide a reliable and easily administered biomarker for earlier diagnosis, assuming further studies confirm these results. “If a physician has a clinical suspicion, selective hyposmia could be used to help make the diagnosis,” Dr. Bohnen said. He also noted that smell testing may be more reliable than motor testing, especially for patients in the earliest stages or for those with comorbid conditions that also affect movement, such as arthritis. Early results from an ongoing study conducted by his group suggest that in first-degree relatives of patients with Parkinson’s disease, a combination of smell and cognitive testing is better at predicting a dopamine deficit than are motor tests.

CAFFEINE AND HYPOSMIA

Hyposmia in first-degree relatives of Parkinson’s disease patients also correlates with low caffeine intake, according to a third study. High caffeine consumption previously has been shown to be associated with a lower risk of Parkinson’s disease. In this study of 159 relatives of patients with Parkinson’s disease, Matthew Stern, MD, and colleagues from Pennsylvania Hospital in Philadelphia found that lifetime caffeine intake was negatively correlated with UPSIT score. Twenty-five percent of those consuming one cup or less per day of a caffeinated beverage over their lifetime were at or below the 10th percentile in UPSIT performance, compared with only 8% of those consuming more than one cup per day. “The effect may be the result of poor olfactory performance in individuals who will go on to develop Parkinson’s disease,” the researchers concluded, although they noted an alternative explanation is that hyposmia is “an intermediate phenotype” for the disease, due to the sharing of epidemiologic associations and risk factors with those for clinical Parkinson’s disease.
NR

—Richard Robinson